New York Police

You can't really make it out, but the badge says "New York Police."  100% legit.  Also, it's made out of cardboard, like a cereal box.

Another Chef's Hat

Another one of Aaron's Chef's hats.  This one is Swedish Chef poofy.

Tiny Sombrero

Tweedle Dee & Tweedle Dum

Jared & Dave's hats from their Tweedle Dee & Tweedle Dum costumes

Goofy

Dan's (impressive) home made Goofy hat for his Halloween costume.

Witch

I bought a witch's hat that was super discounted since Halloween is over.  It was 49¢.

 With a lamp under my head.

Halloween